Popular on EntSun
- Female Motorsports Sponsorship & Expansion; Acquisition Agreement of UAE-Based Sports Incubator by Online Lottery & Sports Game Provider: Lottery.com - 243
- Experience Trembling Firsthand with the New AgeMan® Tremor Simulator - 221
- Edtech Startup Young Commanders Launches 'Visionaries Without Sight' Collection Celebrating Blind and Visually Impaired Historical Figures - 216
- IRF Builders Forum Brings Global Leaders to Washington, D.C. to Advance Religious Freedom Through Cooperative Engagement - 207
- BillBoards Inc. Hits the Road with God Bless America Tour and Reality Series Now Streaming on Tubi TV - 157
- Token-Operated Sake Service Opens at Tobu Nikko Station - 134
- Honoring Black History, Culture, and Community in Fall River - 131
- databahn Launches GenAI Sales Intelligence Platform to Revolutionize Fortune 500 and Global 2000 Account Research - 125
- Byrd Davis Alden & Henrichson Launches Independence Day Safe Ride Initiative with 500 Free Uber Credits - 117
- Agreement to Supply US-Based Defense Provider with Thin-Film Solar Tech for Orbital Application; Ascent Solar Technologies, Inc. (N A S D A Q: ASTI) - 111
Similar on EntSun
- Colbert Packaging Announces WBENC Recognition
- Deaths Spur Closures, but Troubled Teen Camps Must Be Banned, CCHR Warns
- Despite Global Calls for a Ban, US Child Psychiatry Pushes Electroshock for Kids
- Hamvay-Lang and Lampone.hu Join Forces with AIMarketingugynokseg.hu to Elevate Hungarian Lifestyle Brands on the Global Stage
- Keepy Uppy™ by Ollyball Wins Prestigious 2025 Influencer Award from Clamour & The Toy Association; Announces Fall 2025 Launch at Target Stores
- Baker Rights and Coercive Psychiatry: The Citizens Commission on Human Rights of Florida Hosts Monthly Mental Health Law and Human Rights Seminars
- Profiting from Elder Harm: The Push to End Psychiatric Drugging in Nursing Homes
- KeysCaribbean Vacation Home Rentals Offers Last-Minute Booking Discount of 15 Percent
- AI changes cryptocurrency market trading, TWL Miner launches new 1-day contract, giving away over $1 million
- Global Court Momentum Builds Against Forced Psychiatry; CCHR Urges U.S. Reform
Frank A. Lauletta, Esq. publishes comment on recent New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act court decision
EntSun News/10768750
Court held that customized truck with an autoloader tow unit is a sale of "merchandise" under the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act.
SEWELL, N.J. - March 14, 2019 - EntSun -- In a newly published comment, business lawyer Frank A. Lauletta comments on the New Jersey Supreme Court decision addressing the scope of the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act ("CFA"). All The Way Towing, LLC v. Bucks County International, Inc. addresses whether a purchase of a customized truck with an autoloader tow unit is a sale of "merchandise" under the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act (N.J.S.A. 56:8-1 to -210). The CFA prohibits unconscionable commercial practices, deception, and fraud "in connection with the sale or advertisement of any merchandise." N.J.S.A. 56:8-2.
Plaintiff, All The Way Towing, LLC (hereinafter "ATW") contracted to purchase a brand new truck from Bucks County International, Inc. (hereinafter "BCI") with an autoloader tow body manufactured by Dynamic Towing Equipment and Manufacturing, Inc. (hereinafter "Dynamic"). The estimated purchase price was over $160,000 with a $10,000 deposit. Dynamic discovered that its tow body was incompatible with BCI's truck, resulting in modifications to the towing unit. ATW rejected four separate delivery attempts due to deficiencies of the truck and/or towing unit. Eventually, ATW demanded a refund of the deposit, which was rejected by BCI and lawsuit was filed.
More on EntSun News
The trial court dismissed ATW's CFA claim ruling that, because the truck was a custom designed truck, it was not a product offered to the public and, therefore, not "merchandise" under the purview of the CFA.
Under the CFA, "[t]he term 'merchandise' shall include any objects, wares, goods, commodities, services or anything offered, directly or indirectly to the public for sale[.]" The Supreme Court noted that "n light of the Act's original remedial purpose and its subsequent and continuous expansion by the Legislature, courts have consistently recognized that the CFA must be liberally construed." The Court also noted that CFA has been previously interpreted to cover commercial transactions and certain custom goods as well. For example, the New Jersey Supreme Court has already held in Czar, Inc. v. Heath that the "CFA can apply to the building and installation of custom kitchen cabinets." The Court also cited with approval a long list of cases from the New Jersey appellate division that held that customized goods can fall within the scope of CFA. Such goods covered custom auto repair work and a customized yacht.
The Court went on to explain that "In our examination of the matter at hand, the applicability of the CFA does not turn on whether the public at large purchases International trucks onto which a Dynamic 801 tow unit is installed. What is relevant is that a member of the public could, if inclined, purchase an operational tow truck consisting of a Dynamic 801 tow body installed onto an International chassis. It is consistent with the intent of the CFA to protect consumers regardless of the popularity of the product or service sold or advertised. To promote consistency in the application of the requirement that a product be offered to the public when evaluating a private individual CFA action, we hold that the availability requirement can be met by showing that any member of the public could purchase the product or service, if willing and able, regardless of whether such a purchase is popular." Therefore, the Court held that the transaction in question was covered by the CFA.
More on EntSun News
The case is All The Way Towing, LLC v. Bucks County International, Inc., A-66/67-17.
*** Frank Lauletta is an experienced corporate attorney who has many years of "hands on" experience in private and public companies. His practice focuses heavily on representing and counseling a broad array of companies in corporate transactions such as venture capital, corporate finance, and mergers and acquisitions.
Attorney Profile: https://solomonlawguild.com/frank-a-lauletta
Blog of Frank Lauletta: https://franklaulettablog.blogspot.com/
Plaintiff, All The Way Towing, LLC (hereinafter "ATW") contracted to purchase a brand new truck from Bucks County International, Inc. (hereinafter "BCI") with an autoloader tow body manufactured by Dynamic Towing Equipment and Manufacturing, Inc. (hereinafter "Dynamic"). The estimated purchase price was over $160,000 with a $10,000 deposit. Dynamic discovered that its tow body was incompatible with BCI's truck, resulting in modifications to the towing unit. ATW rejected four separate delivery attempts due to deficiencies of the truck and/or towing unit. Eventually, ATW demanded a refund of the deposit, which was rejected by BCI and lawsuit was filed.
More on EntSun News
- Josh and Heidi Follow Up the Much Anticipated and Successful Launch of the "Spreading the Good BUZZ" Podcast with a Personal Request
- The Battle for the Enchanted Forest Brings Fantasy, Fun, and Fundraising!
- Revolutionary Blockchain Platform Okh Finance Announces Okh Finance(OKKH) Token Launch to Transform Global Asset Leasing Market
- Cover Girl Finalist Teisha Mechetti Questions Legitimacy of Inked Originals Competition, Demands Transparency
- Easton & Easton, LLP Files Suit Against The Dwelling Place Anaheim & Vineyard USA Over Abuse Allegations
The trial court dismissed ATW's CFA claim ruling that, because the truck was a custom designed truck, it was not a product offered to the public and, therefore, not "merchandise" under the purview of the CFA.
Under the CFA, "[t]he term 'merchandise' shall include any objects, wares, goods, commodities, services or anything offered, directly or indirectly to the public for sale[.]" The Supreme Court noted that "n light of the Act's original remedial purpose and its subsequent and continuous expansion by the Legislature, courts have consistently recognized that the CFA must be liberally construed." The Court also noted that CFA has been previously interpreted to cover commercial transactions and certain custom goods as well. For example, the New Jersey Supreme Court has already held in Czar, Inc. v. Heath that the "CFA can apply to the building and installation of custom kitchen cabinets." The Court also cited with approval a long list of cases from the New Jersey appellate division that held that customized goods can fall within the scope of CFA. Such goods covered custom auto repair work and a customized yacht.
The Court went on to explain that "In our examination of the matter at hand, the applicability of the CFA does not turn on whether the public at large purchases International trucks onto which a Dynamic 801 tow unit is installed. What is relevant is that a member of the public could, if inclined, purchase an operational tow truck consisting of a Dynamic 801 tow body installed onto an International chassis. It is consistent with the intent of the CFA to protect consumers regardless of the popularity of the product or service sold or advertised. To promote consistency in the application of the requirement that a product be offered to the public when evaluating a private individual CFA action, we hold that the availability requirement can be met by showing that any member of the public could purchase the product or service, if willing and able, regardless of whether such a purchase is popular." Therefore, the Court held that the transaction in question was covered by the CFA.
More on EntSun News
- AI Visibility: The Key to Beating Google's AI Overviews and Regaining Traffic
- Stuck Doing Math or Figuring Out Life's Numbers? Calculator.now Makes It Stupidly Simple
- Colbert Packaging Announces WBENC Recognition
- DivX Empowers Media Enthusiasts with Free Expert Guides for Advanced MP4 Management
- Bay Street Yard to host "Love Island" finale watch party July 13
The case is All The Way Towing, LLC v. Bucks County International, Inc., A-66/67-17.
*** Frank Lauletta is an experienced corporate attorney who has many years of "hands on" experience in private and public companies. His practice focuses heavily on representing and counseling a broad array of companies in corporate transactions such as venture capital, corporate finance, and mergers and acquisitions.
Attorney Profile: https://solomonlawguild.com/frank-a-lauletta
Blog of Frank Lauletta: https://franklaulettablog.blogspot.com/
Source: Lauletta Birnbaum Law Firm
0 Comments
Latest on EntSun News
- Heritage at South Brunswick Offers Immediate Townhome Appointments and Special Mortgage Incentive Fast-Moving Sales
- American Made Ivey Abitz Bespoke Clothing Travels for Summer
- NASA Collaborative Agreement for Supply of Thin-Film Solar Tech for Orbital Application to Advance Development of Thin-Film PV Power Beaming: $ASTI
- Exciting New Era of Sports, Entertainment & Gaming Innovation Spotlighted by Rebrand of Expanding AI Driven, Online Fan Engagement Company: SEGG Media
- Service Ninjas Debuts First-of-Its-Kind "Membership" Platform for Home Service Pros
- Bruce In The USA Brings Immersive Bruce Springsteen Celebration to Frederick This October
- BIYA Forecasts 2025 Surge with ¥300M ($41.8 M USD) in Revenue and ¥25M Profit from Cloud Based HR Solutions: Baiya Intl. Group (N A S D A Q: BIYA)
- Paul E. Saperstein Co. Announces Geographic Expansion of Auction Services
- Florida Broker Bent Danholm Featured in the Daily Mail's U.S. Real Estate Coverage
- Robin Launches Legal Intelligence Platform to solve intelligence gap in Fortune 500 legal teams
- Melissa B. Releases Digitally Independent: Empowering Music Artists with AI and Brand Strategy
- Mental: Elderly Abuse a Documentary
- Consumer Accountability Alliance Issues Formal Notice Alleging Proximate Liability for Medical Harm
- Rising to New Heights in the Mile High City with Destination: Scientology, Denver
- The City's Largest and Most Elegant Dinner Party Returns on September 13, 2025
- Utah Metal Fabricator Titan Forge Builds Momentum with Custom Steel Projects and Spiral Staircases
- Jason Koch: Pioneering the Future of Real Estate Development in New Jersey
- Voting Opens Tonight for the 2025 Spin Awards Honoring Excellence in Christian Gospel Radio
- Introducing LK Blue: The Cool-Girl Denim Brand That's Redefining LA Style Launches E-Commerce
- Bach and Beyond: Cellists Return to the Beach for 2nd Annual Bethany Beach Cellofest